Skip to main content

After hours: voicemail, a live answering service, or your cell phone?

Answering calls well — IBeXc guides for Alaska businesses

Your office closes at five. Your customers don’t always get the memo. A furnace quits in Wasilla at 9 p.m., a lodge guest on the Kenai has a question on Sunday morning, a client in Fairbanks wants to confirm tomorrow’s appointment at 6:30 a.m. What happens when they call?

Most businesses end up with one of three answers: voicemail, a live answering service, or the owner’s cell phone. Each one fits some businesses and wears others down. Here’s a plain comparison, and how to set your phone system to handle it for you.

Option 1: Voicemail

A clear after-hours greeting and a voicemail box is the simplest choice. It costs the least, needs no one on call and works well when after-hours calls are rare and rarely urgent.

The downside is the caller experience. Many people hang up on voicemail, and some of them call a competitor who answers. If you go this route, make the greeting useful: your hours, when you’ll call back, and what to do if it truly can’t wait. Then turn on voicemail to email so messages land in your inbox the moment they’re left and you can return them first thing, or sooner.

Option 2: A live answering service

A live answering service means a real person picks up after hours. They greet callers in your business name, take messages, handle urgent calls the way you tell them to, and in many cases book appointments.

This costs more than voicemail, but callers talk to a person instead of a beep. It suits businesses where a missed call means a lost job or an unhappy client: trades, property management, medical and professional offices, and anyone with customers who expect an answer. We go into more detail in The case for a live answering service.

Option 3: Your cell phone

Plenty of Alaska owners simply take after-hours calls themselves. The caller reaches a real person who knows the business, and it costs nothing extra.

The hidden cost is you. When every call can reach you at dinner, on the weekend or on a fishing trip, the workday never really ends. It also doesn’t scale: once you have staff, one person holding the phone every night leads to burnout. A rotating on-call schedule helps, as long as calls reach the on-call person without anyone giving out their personal number.

Side by side

Voicemail Live answering service Your cell phone
Cost Lowest A monthly charge No added cost, but your time
Caller experience A recording; some callers hang up A real person every time A real person, if you pick up
Owner burnout Low Low High over time
Urgent calls Wait until morning Handled by your instructions Handled by you
Fits best when Calls are rare and can wait Every call matters A small team shares on-call duty

Many businesses mix them. Voicemail on weeknights, an answering service on weekends and holidays, and an on-call cell phone during storm season. There’s no single right answer.

Let the phone system change over on its own

Whichever option you choose, nobody should have to remember to flip a setting on the way out the door. A hosted phone system handles this with time-of-day routing: a schedule that tells the system where calls go at different times.

  • Business hours: calls ring the office as usual.
  • Weeknights: calls go to voicemail, an answering service or the on-call phone.
  • Weekends: a different path if you like, such as the answering service.
  • Holidays: set the dates in advance, and the system follows its holiday plan on those days.

If you want to send calls to your cell phone, the Bria Enterprise app is a cleaner way to do it than forwarding. Your office extension rings in the app, and when you call someone back, they see the office caller ID instead of your personal number. On-call duty can move from person to person without anyone’s cell number getting passed around.

For closing early on a snow day, the schedule can be overridden in a moment so calls go straight to the after-hours path. We set that up so it’s simple for whoever closes the office.

How IBeXc helps

We design and program your after-hours routing for you. Tell us your hours, your holidays and who should get what kind of call, and our Anchorage team builds the schedule and tests it with you. If your needs change in summer or winter, we change it. There are no long-term contracts, so your setup can change as your business does.

For more ways to make sure callers reach someone during the day as well, see Never miss a call: when you’re busy, out or closed.

Tell us how you handle calls after hours today, and we’ll show you what a schedule could look like for your office. Get a quote for your office →